Evening Star Coffee Roasters- Coffee Service & Coffee Roastery

Jody runs Evening Star Coffee Roasters, and Jody's name turns up in nearly every customer note. That's usually a sign of an owner-operator doing the work themselves, and here it is. The shop in Avon sells beans only (no cafe seating mentioned), ships nationwide, and throws free sample bags into orders. Church groups and out-of-state customers re-order regularly, which is the quiet proof a roaster needs.

The Jamaican Me Happy blend is the runaway favorite. Order it once and the name stops feeling cute. The Evening Star single origin Papua New Guinea is the move for anyone who wants something less blended and more place-specific. Chocolate hazelnut is the dependable flavored option. Peppermint mocha shows up around the holidays.

This is a roaster, not a cafe. Whole bean or ground, by mail or pickup. If you want to sit down with a latte, go elsewhere. If you want fresh beans from someone who personally sends them, this is the operation. Jody has clearly built it on relationships, and the people who buy here become the people who keep buying here.