McCullagh Coffee

McCullagh Coffee has been roasting in Buffalo since 1867. It's mostly a wholesale roaster, supplying hotels and restaurants, with coffee and water delivery around Buffalo, Rochester, Syracuse and Erie. They also do contract roasting and private label. You can buy at the counter on Swan Street, but there's no café.

The Sultana Blend is their best-known coffee. The Holiday Blend is smooth, and Sticky Bun is a favorite flavor. The red bag of 100% Arabica is the everyday pick, and there are K-cups. They also carry fair trade, organic and Rainforest Alliance coffees. Their customer service is quick to make things right.